
You’ve heard of the saying, “When in Rome,” right? Well, when I was in Rome recently, I decided to eat like the Romans. When I say Rome of course, I mean Reykjavík and when I say Romans, I mean Icelandic people. It sounds odd I know, but it’s a metaphor, so you have to… ahhh, I can’t be bothered to explain it.
On my first night in Reykjavík, I decided to splash out on some fine-dining Icelandic cuisine. I couldn’t decide whether to go for the lamb, or the puffin, or the seafood, so I went for the whole lot, Tapas-style. My “Icelandic Feast” consisted of the following;

Smoked Puffin with Blueberry “Brennivín” Sauce
When I tell people I’ve eaten Puffin, I’ve mostly been met with frowns. But they don’t know how good it tastes. The shredded Puffin I had was dense and meaty. The main flavour was quite fishy but it was also quite gamey. I actually mistook the sauce for a plum sauce, such was the similarity. It complemented the puffin perfectly. I could have eaten more of it, but alas, I only had a sampler.
Baked Lobster Tails in Garlic Butter
Man, these were good! They came to the table fizzing in the garlic oil. The meat was surprisingly delicate and tasted sumptuous. I could have eaten about 20 of them.

Grilled Icelandic Lamb Samfaina
No, I don’t know what Samfaina is either. All I know is it’s good. I’ve never had lamb before (crazy, huh?), so I approached this with caution. I needn’t have. It was great! The meat was tough, but juicy and chewy. I really enjoyed it. I can’t say I’ll be eating it more often though. I’m just not a red meat kind-of guy.
Icelandic Sea Trout with Red Pepper Salsa
The fish was deliciously light and moist. It was a lot like salmon. The skin was cooked to perfection and added a nice crunch. I even liked the pepper salsa, even though I’m not a great fan of pepper.

Pan-Fried Monkfish with Lobster Sauce
A lovely, dense fillet of fish with a delicate, meaty flavour. The sauce was rich and creamy.
Minke Whale with Cranberry Sauce
Hmmmm. Nah. I really couldn’t bring myself to eat this. I didn’t even arrive at the table. I made an early substitution for;

Pan fried Salt Fish with Mashed Sweet Potato
What a choice! This was easily my favourite dish. I could have quite happily eaten a full serving of the mash on it’s own. It was so creamy and sweet! The salt fish was barely cooked (in a good way). It was so moist, so dense, so incredibly delicious. I loved it.

Chocolate Cake with a Berry Compote and Fresh Whipped Cream
I had just enough rook for pudding, And thank goodness I did, for it was worth making room for. Like most of the main courses, the cake was very dense. There’s no other word to describe it. It was like a thick slice of tort. It also came with a strawberry, another weird berry and a swirl of delicious, rich custard. Awesome!
The meal was served with an entire loaf of sliced bread with masses of Spanish-style Tapanades and a jug of water. It was also served with a shot of Brennivín, also known as svarti dauði (“black death”). The name literally translates in English as ‘burning wine’. And boy, did it burn! I wanted to cough after downing it, but couldn’t muster the energy to do so, such was the burning, so instead I noisily exhaled. Seriously, it nearly killed me. Never again!
Was the whole meal worth £30. Just. I obviously would have liked it to have been cheaper, but I went knowing it was that much and happily paid up at the end of the meal. The food was cooked to perfection and beautifully presented. Service was friendly, professional and very quick. The atmosphere in the restaurant was moody and unique. It was an experience I’m glad I had. And that’s what life is all about, right? So £30 is a drop in the ocean.
Next time you’re in Reykjavík, eat out at Tapas Barinn. It’s a great way to celebrate your arrival in one of the world’s coolest places.